Her rep may have denied rumours that the actress had secretly gotten engaged to her Egor Tarabasov but Lindsay has still got us thinking otherwise.
The 29-year-old, who may or may not be engaged, showed off what can only be described as a stunning and very shiny new sparkler amply sitting on her ring finger during a Duran Duran concert in New York on Tuesday.
Adding more fuel to the fire, the actress was joined by her 22-year-old boyfriend of seven months sister Ali and her formerly estranged parents Michael and Dina Lohan.
With her ring soaking up the spotlight, Lindsay looked phenomenal in tassel-covered white jumpsuit featuring a plunging neckline.
Clearly having a fabulous time, the Parent Trap star was asked on stage by the 80s band where she performed her spoken word portion of their 2015 single Dancephobia.
According to TMZ, the Russian businessman "popped the question over the weekend, and LiLo said ... "Da!", that's Russian for yes.
However Lindsay's rep, Hunter Frederick, debunked any marriage talk, telling People, "The story is untrue and holds no merit."
Despite the wedding riddle, Lindsay adores her man.
"I haven't known Egor for that long," the 29-year-old former child star told The Sun last month.
"We've been together for about seven months. He is a great guy. I met him in the summer. I'm really happy."
And Egor has got mum’s seal of approval.
"We love him. He is a sweetheart,” Dina Lohan told ET about the Russian entrepreneur.
I guess the only thing that we’re left with is: Lindsay are you trying to fool us with the rock that you got!?